Return fraud in eCommerce is a deceptive practice where individuals exploit a retailer's return policy and procedures for personal gain. The problem is substantial: return fraud comprises $103 billion or 15.14% of total returns in 2024.
BORIS Fraud Alert
12.7% of Buy Online, Return In-Store (BORIS) returns are fraudulent -- estimated to be 48% higher than returns to non-store locations.
The Most Common Types of Return Fraud
Wardrobing
Also called "wear and return," this involves purchasing items, using them briefly, then returning them claiming they're unused. Common in fashion, electronics, and luxury goods sectors.
Returning Stolen Merchandise
Customers attempt to return items they never purchased from the retailer, having acquired them through theft or illicit means.
Empty Box Returns
Fraudsters mail empty boxes while claiming to return purchased items, retaining merchandise while requesting full refunds or replacements.
Multiple Returns
Repeated buying and returning to exploit welcome discounts, cashback offers, and promotional deals.
Package Refusal
Customers refuse delivery upon arrival, then claim refunds while asserting non-receipt, avoiding return shipping fees.
Friendly Fraud
Customers purchase items via credit card, receive products, then dispute charges claiming unauthorized transactions.
Tips for Detecting Return Fraud
- Closely examine merchandise -- inspect items thoroughly for wear, damage, or tampering on high-value items
- Implement receipt verification -- require proof of purchase and verify against order databases using barcode or QR scanning
- Use Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) systems -- require pre-approval before returns to track patterns
- Train employees -- include fraud detection in onboarding covering common tactics, counterfeit identification, and reporting
Best Practices for Reducing Return Scams
Establish Firm Return Policies
Clear policies specifying eligible items, return timeframes, and required documentation reduce ambiguity and disputes.
Regularly Review Transaction and Chargeback Data
Analyze purchase and returns history to identify suspicious patterns. Track customers with chargeback histories, monitor chargebacks by category and region, and compare rates against industry benchmarks.
Maintain Tightly Integrated Systems
Ensure real-time data synchronization across platforms to prevent fraudsters from exploiting delays. Integration should include eCommerce platforms, inventory management, CRM systems, payment processors, and fraud detection software.
What to Do When Encountering Return Fraud
- Dispute chargebacks -- file disputes with payment processors, providing proof of purchase, tracking information, and return policy documentation.
- Restrict or ban chronic returners -- add excessive returners to blacklists or limit return frequency.
- Report fraud or pursue legal action -- contact appropriate authorities or pursue legal remedies for significant fraud cases.
Prevention represents the most effective fraud management strategy. Implementing solid policies, regularly analyzing data, training employees, and maintaining system integration create comprehensive protection against return scams.
Ready to transform your post-purchase experience?
See how parcelLab can help you turn every delivery and return into a loyalty-building moment.